A friend of mine who writes M/M romances (Jane Davitt; I highly recommend her novel Room At The Top, which she wrote with Alexa Snow) pointed me to this post by Smart Bitches, Trashy Books about a chapter of RWA banning same-sex romances from their annual contest.
What I find rather baffling is that this ban takes place because some members of the chapter are ‘uncomfortable’ with such material, even in sweet, sex-less romances, while at the same time the rules state that “We recruit judges nationwide and even worldwide”.
So… the members who don’t care for this genre wouldn’t have been asked to read or judge it… but the fact that they personally don’t like it means that the genre is banned?
It’s one thing for a reader not to enjoy a particular genre, whether because of the setting or gender of the characters. Everyone is entitled to their reading tastes, and whether they mirror their attitude in ‘real life’ or not is not for me to judge.
It’s a different thing altogether for an organization to discriminate against said genre. I’m not a member of RWA. If this behavior is accepted in this organization, I don’t think I’ll ever care to join. What I did instead was sign this petition.
A week or so ago, Megan at Riverina Romantics posted about M/M romances and asked her readers to share their opinions. Here’s the answer I posted about why I write M/M… and why I’ll keep writing it.
~
When I first started writing, way back then in my fanfiction days, I was strictly a het writer… but I would sneak to the ‘other side’ and read M/M stories, too worried about what anyone would think of me reading them to dare leave feedback for the authors. And then one day it hit me. What was I worried about? I was reading stories that told about love, and relationships, and heartbreak, and okay, *sex*, but all these were the same things I wrote about in my stories. The gender of the characters didn’t change anything.
With much trepidation – and it turned out, to the happiness of my readers – I popped my M/M cherry and started writing both M/M and M/F to the point that, today, I write both without ever thinking twice about it. I think most writers focus on one or the other, but for me it’s never been an option. I enjoy both too much.
I know some of my readers might not appreciate my M/M – I know it because I’ve heard from some of them, especially when I write a threesome and my heroes ‘play’ with each other as well as with the heroine. In Living Out of the Box, in particular, one reader was really upset that the hero, Anando, seemed to enjoy bottoming for another man under the heroine’s directions. I am sorry when that happens, but I’d never NOT write a scene or a book because of fears I might turn off readers.
The one limit I have is that I don’t write full F/F stories. (I’ve had very minor glimpses of it when the story called for it, but nothing major.) It’s not because I have an issue with two women together, but rather because of the way I write. I’m a very visual person, and when I write I ‘see’ the scene in my mind. It’s just a lot more fun for me to mentally ogle characters with dangly bits (or not so dangly if you know what I mean… ) than to imagine characters with boobs. I’ve got some of those and some days they’re more trouble than they’re worth